Magnolia Bakery Menu With Prices [May 2024 Updated]

Magnolia Bakery Menu With Prices

Last updated on May 1st, 2024 at 04:48 pm

Magnolia Bakery is one of the well-known bakery chains established in New York City. This bakery-café caters to a variety of desserts however, its cupcake and banana pudding have their charm. The delicious desserts at this bakery are sure to melt in your mouth and warm your heart under the affordable Magnolia Bakery menu with prices.

Magnolia Bakery is regarded as one of the most famous bakery chains germinated in the heart of New York City. The Magnolia Bakery NYC is one of the native’s favorite bakery junctions.

The Magnolia Bakery cakes and cupcakes are not only dreamy but are available at reasonable Magnolia Bakery menu prices.

This article will elaborate on the latest Magnolia Bakery menu and prices so that you can visit your nearest Magnolia Bakery location and enjoy the Magnolia Bakery goodness.

Magnolia Bakery Menu With Prices

Magnolia Bakery Menu And Prices
Image Credit:-

Sampler Pack Menu

“Best of Magnolia Bakery” Baked Fresh Sampler Pack$73.00
“Best of Magnolia Bakery” Sampler Pack$45.00
“Best of Magnolia Bakery” Holiday Sampler Pack$138.00
Chocolate Decadence Sampler Pack$73.00
Holiday Pie Bundle$50.00

World-Famous Banana Pudding Menu

World-Famous Banana Pudding Variety Multipack$63.00
Classic Banana Pudding Party Bowl$48.00
Classic Banana Pudding Cup$4.95
Classic Banana Pudding Multipack$58.00
DIY Banana Pudding Kit$30.00
Gluten Free Banana Pudding Party Bowl$53.00
Red Velvet Banana Pudding Party Bowl$53.00
Chocolate Hazelnut Banana Pudding Party Bowl$58.00
Gluten-Free Banana Pudding Multipack$63.00
Red Velvet Banana Pudding Cup$5.45

Cookies Menu

Banana Pudding Cookies$22.20
Cookie Assortment$45.00
Holiday Cookie Sampler Pack$51.00
Chocolate Chunk Cookies$18.00
Spritz Cookies$18.00
Red Velvet Banana Pudding Cookies$25.00
Cutout Sugar Cookies$17.60
Premium Holiday Cookie Gift Tin$73.00
Chocolate Crinkle Cookies$13.20
Jammy Thumbprint Cookies$13.20
Sno-ball Cookies$13.20
Snickerdoodle Cookies$13.20
Gingersnap Cookies$13.20

Cupcakes Menu

Christmas Mini Cupcakes$24.00
Holiday Candy Store Mini Cupcake Assortment$45.00
Christmas Cupcakes$24.90
Candy Store Mini Cupcake Assortment$45.00
Chocolate Lovers’ Cupcake Assortment$58.00
Birthday Cupcakes$24.90
The Carrie Cupcakes$24.90
Red Velvet Cupcakes$24.90
Flower Cupcakes$35.70
Confetti Cupcake Assortment$24.90
Classic Mini Cupcake Assortment$22.00
Classic Vanilla Mini Cupcakes$22.00
Classic Chocolate Mini Cupcakes$22.00
Classic Vanilla Cupcakes$24.90
Classic Chocolate Cupcakes$24.90
Classic Cupcake Assortment$24.90
I “CC” New York Cupcake$24.90

Cakes Menu

Confetti Cake$55.00
Chocolate Cake$50.00
Celebration Cake$58.00
Vanilla Cake$50.00
Tis Lit Cake$55.00
Carrot Cake$55.00
Red Velvet Cake$55.00
German Chocolate Cake$55.00
Hummingbird Cake$55.00
Flourless Chocolate Cake$43.00

Cheesecakes Menu

Caramel Pecan Cheesecake$8.25
Vanilla Cheesecake$50.00
Red Velvet Cheesecake$50.00
Vanilla Bean Cheesecake$8.25
Red Velvet Cheesecake$8.25
Blueberry Cheesecake$8.25
Key Lime Cheesecake$8.25

Brownies & Bars Menu

Brownie, Magic Bar & Blondie Combo$45.00
Brownie & Blondie Combo$31.00
Peppermint Bark$15.00
Chocolate Toffee Bark$15.00
Lemon Bar$7.00
Double Fudge Brownie$7.40
Chocolate Chunk Blondie$7.40

Icebox Desserts Menu

Classic Icebox Cake$38.00
Blueberry Jamboree Icebox Bar$7.00
Peanut Butter Icebox Pie$12.00
Banana Cream Icebox Pie$30.00
Chocolate Pudding Icebox Pie$12.00
Key Lime Icebox Bar$7.00
Peanut Butter Icebox Bar$7.00

Disclaimer: We do our best to keep our menu prices up-to-date, but they may not always reflect the latest changes or vary between different locations of the eatery. For the most current pricing info, we recommend reaching out directly to the eatery location you’re planning to visit.

Magnolia Bakery History

Magnolia Bakery Menu Prices
Image Credit:-

The first Magnolia Bakery location opened at 401 Beeker Street, West Village, Manhattan in the year 1966.

The founder Jennifer Appel and Allysa Torey curated this standing bakery to initiate the cupcake craze that emerged back in the 1990s.

Initially, Magnolia Bakery catered to a variety of cakes, however, started baking cupcakes out of leftover cake dough.

These made-from-scratch cupcakes became a game changer for the brand. The sweet smell of freshly baked cakes, cupcakes, pies, and pudding ingratiated a swamp of neighborhood inside the store thus laying the grand success story of the Magnolia Bakery.

Founder Jennifer Appel left the brand in 1999 and then the company was eventually sold to Steve Abrams in 2006.

Finally, in 2021, the company was sold to a private equity firm that was co-founded by the developer of Hudson Yards Stephen Ross and Bobbie Lloyd is the current CEO of the company.

As a part of the development, Magnolia Bakery expanded over the country to reach several American states and spread the charm of its freshly baked delicacy. Magnolia Bakery locations branched out to Boston, Chicago, Los Angeles, and Washington DC.

The brand has also gone international with the inception of a location in UAE and subsequently at Abu Dabi.

Currently, Magnolia Bakery has many international outlets starting from 4 locations in Qatar, and the first outlet in Banglore, India in 2019, and then propagating to Hyderabad.

Magnolia Bakery has been part of very famous popular culture and has featured in several shows like S*ex in the City, Lazy Sunday, The Devil Wears Prada, Spin City, and Veronica Mars.

Apart from having pocket-friendly Magnolia Bakery menu prices, the company is known for its amazing ambiance that has the sweet aroma of cupcakes and is sure to warm your heart with an amazing time.

Magnolia Bakery Review

Magnolia Bakery Menu With Pictures usamenuprices
Image Credit:-

The Magnolia Bakery menu has a wide range of cakes, cupcakes, puddings, brownies, icebox desserts, and other baked goodies.

If you are a first-time visitor at Magnolia Bakery, you can ask for sampler packs which are miniature versions of their supremely delicious craftings.

The store opening hours vary from Magnolia Bakery location to location as the brand has both in-country and international locations.

The Magnolia Bakery menu caters to baked goodies like cakes, cupcakes, pies, puddings, cookies, icebox desserts, brownies candy bars, and the like.

At Magnolia Bakery, you cannot keep your hand from getting dirty and your mouth full from the sweetest and yummiest confectionery range. The Magnolia Bakery banana pudding has its fan base across the American states.

Most of the Magnolia Bakery banana pudding recipes come in various flavors like Chocolate Hazelnut part bowl ($58+), Red Velvet ($5.45), Classic Banana ($4.50), etc.

These banana puddings can also be packed for you as an assortment for a takeaway which is also available in a party pack ($48+).

You can satiate your sugar rush from the out-from-oven Magnolia Bakery cookies like Red Velvet Banana Pudding Cookies ($25.00), Chocolate Chunk Cookies ($18.00), and the like.

For the holiday season, you can order their cupcake assortment that comes in varying flavors like Holiday Candy Store ($45.00), Candy Store Mini Cupcakes, Fall Mini Cupcakes ($24.00), Red Velvet ($24.90), Birthday Party ($24.50), etc.

For any occasion, be it birthdays or anniversaries or simply for celebrating the little joys of life, the Magnolia Bakery cakes range is made just for you.

Starting from Confetti Cake ($55) to Tis Lit Cake ($55), you can also have chocolate and vanilla cake at $50 at the store.

The Double Fudge ($7.40) and Peppermint Brownies ($15.00+) are some of the most sold products during the holiday season.

The Chocolate Pudding Icebox Pie is one of the kid’s favorite desserts. The Blueberry Jamboree Icebox Bar is a must-have at the Magnolia Bakery store.

Magnolia Bakery also hosts a wide cheesecake range along with assorted holiday packs made just for you and your family.

The Magnolia Bakery menu with prices is worth every penny owing to the high-quality products and mouthwatering confectionary treats.

How to Order Online From Magnolia Bakery?

Magnolia Bakery Order Online usamenuprices
Image Credit:-

If you want to check the menu prices of Magnolia Bakery for different locations or you want to order online, then you can follow the steps given below.

  1. First, go to and select your nearest location.
  2. After selecting your nearest location, the menu prices of Magnolia Bakery of that particular location will be displayed (here you just check the menu prices of Magnolia Bakery based on your preferred location).
  3. Now, select all the items that you want to order online and add them to your cart.
  4. Now, go to checkout and select whether you want to pick up the order or get delivery.
  5. In the next step, sign in to your account if you have one or you can create a new one.
  6. After that, fill in some of your personal details, make the payment, and place your order.

In this way, you can order online or check the latest menu prices of Magnolia Bakery for different locations.

For more information about Magnolia Bakery, visit their official website.

Check More Menus Below:

Posted by
Pankaj verma

Pankaj Verma is a food enthusiast and full-time blogger dedicated to exploring the culinary landscape. A BCA graduate, Pankaj's passion for dining experiences led him to launch his blog, where he carefully curates menu prices and insights from eateries across the United States and beyond. With a keen eye for detail and a deep appreciation for diverse cuisines, Pankaj's blog offers a valuable resource for food lovers seeking comprehensive information about their favorite dining destinations.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.